A Fragile Victory for Pro-European Forces: Analyzing the Recent Elections in Romania, Poland, and Portugal
May 18, 2025, will be remembered as a pivotal day in European politics, marked by three significant elections across Romania, Poland, and Portugal. While there were concerns that pro-Russian, anti-Brussels, and populist candidates might dominate these contests, the opposite emerged as pro-European candidates secured notable victories, prompting a collective sigh of relief in Brussels.
In Romania, Nicușor Dan, the centrist candidate and the current mayor of Bucharest, won the presidential runoff with a decisive 55.1% of the vote against ultranationalist George Simion, who garnered 46.4%. This victory was particularly important as Simion had been a formidable threat, especially following his strong performance in the first round, which had raised alarms about the rise of far-right politics amid Russian interference.
Dan’s victory was hailed as a moment of hope for Romania, highlighting the electorate's desire for profound change. The President of the European Council, António Costa, echoed this sentiment, celebrating the election outcome as a reflection of Romanians' commitment to the European project. Dan, described as a math genius with a calm demeanor, emphasized that his win signifies the will of a community of Romanians seeking change.
Simion's acknowledgment of defeat was an important step that could prevent unrest among his supporters, especially since he had previously attempted to claim victory before the official results were announced. Despite losing, Simion’s support base of over five million voters remains a considerable factor in Romania's political landscape.
In Poland, the liberal candidate Rafał Trzaskowski emerged victorious in the first round of the national presidential elections with 31.36% of the votes, edging out ultraconservative candidate Karol Nawrocki, who received 29.54%. With the second round approaching, Trzaskowski faces a challenging contest against the ultraconservative opposition, which has dominated the country's political scene in recent years. The stakes are high, as Trzaskowski represents economic liberalism and social policies aimed at safeguarding civil rights, contrasting sharply with the previous ultraconservative governance.
Meanwhile, in Portugal, the election results marked a significant shift in the political landscape. Prime Minister Luís Montenegro’s centrist coalition secured 32.10% of the votes, but he will govern as a minority, having rejected alliances with the far-right Chega party, which has rapidly gained influence to become the third-largest force in parliament. The fragmentation of the Portuguese political system, characterized by the rise of Chega and the decline of the Socialist Party, prompts questions about future governance and political stability in the country where traditional bipartisanship has been disrupted.
Collectively, these electoral outcomes reflect both hope and caution for the future of European democracy. While pro-European candidates have emerged victorious, the growing presence of populist and ultranationalist forces underscores an ongoing struggle—one marked by increasing polarization and fatigue with traditional governance structures.
Despite the success on the electoral front, antidemocratic sentiments have not diminished; they continue to pose a significant risk to European unity and democratic norms. As the continent grapples with these challenges, it is essential to remain vigilant against the allure of far-right ideologies that threaten the stability achieved through democratic processes.
In summary, while the recent elections in Romania, Poland, and Portugal may signify a temporary reprieve for pro-European forces, the evolving political dynamics highlight the necessity for continued effort to uphold democratic principles in the face of rising extremism. The path ahead is fraught with challenges, and European leaders must navigate this complex landscape to safeguard the political future of the continent.
Related Sources: