Apple Faces Major Setback in €13 Billion Tax Battle with EU
Apple has lost a significant €13 billion tax battle against the European Commission in a ruling by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) that strengthens regulatory efforts to tackle favorable tax agreements for multinational corporations. This long-awaited decision overturns a lower court’s previous ruling in favor of Apple and affirms the Commission’s 2016 determination that Ireland illegally aided the tech giant by allowing it to benefit from unlawful tax breaks.
The ECJ's judgment means that Ireland is now required to recover the €13 billion in illegal tax benefits that Apple accrued from its business operations in Europe, specifically profits generated outside the United States. This outcome marks a triumph for Margrethe Vestager, the EU's competition chief, who pioneered the investigation in 2016, concluding that Apple's arrangements resulted in significantly lower tax payments compared to its rivals.
The legal battle began in 2016 when the European Commission ordered Apple to repay the staggering sum, owing to what officials described as a blatant underpayment of taxes from 2003 to 2014. The Commission claimed that Apple's effective tax rate in 2014 was a minuscule 0.005%, largely due to favorable rulings from the Irish authorities. Apple has consistently rejected these claims, framing them as politically motivated and emphasizing its status as a major taxpayer worldwide.
In a 2020 ruling, the General Court, the EU's second-highest court, annulled the Commission's decision, arguing that it had failed to demonstrate that Apple had received an illegal economic advantage. However, the European Commission appealed this ruling, leading the Advocate General, Giovanni Pitruzzella, to suggest last year that the ECJ should overturn the General Court’s decision due to legal missteps.
Following the ECJ’s ruling, Apple stated, "This case has never been about how much tax we pay but which government we are required to pay it to. We always pay all the taxes we owe wherever we operate and there has never been a special deal." Apple remains adamant that it is a crucial driver of economic growth and innovation across Europe and worldwide.
In addition to Apple, the ECJ also upheld a €2.4 billion antitrust fine against Google in a separate case, highlighting a broader trend of European authorities exerting pressure on major tech companies regarding their business practices and tax obligations. Google expressed disappointment over the ruling, stating that its compliance measures have rectified the issues cited by the Commission since 2017.
As the EU continues to tighten its grip on multinational corporations’ tax arrangements, this ruling may have far-reaching implications not only for Apple but for other tech giants as well. With Vestager's term coming to an end later this year, her legacy as a formidable enforcer of competition and tax laws within the EU will likely influence how similar cases are approached in the future.
Related Sources: