Brotherhood of Macarena Issues Apology Following Controversial Restoration of Virgin Image

The Governing Board of the Brotherhood of Macarena has publicly apologized to all brothers and devotees for the moral and devotional damage that may have arisen from decisions made after the recent restoration intervention on the image of María Santísima de la Esperanza Macarena. This statement was released on the Brotherhood's website following considerable backlash from the community. In their announcement, the Brotherhood expressed regret over the delay in convening an extraordinary Board meeting on the matter. The meeting, held this Monday, aimed to gather all relevant information and technical reports regarding the restoration incident to determine the appropriate course of action. The statement reveals that both the Steward and the Sacristan of Our Lady of Hope have decided to resign, effective upon resolution of the current issues surrounding the restoration. To ensure further accountability and oversight, the Governing Board has enlisted the Andalusian Institute of Historical Heritage (IAPH) to supervise future actions regarding the venerable image. In May 2024, the Brotherhood had sought a comprehensive report from Professor Francisco Arquillo Torres, highlighting the conservation status of their titular images. The report detailed necessary maintenance actions that included the removal of a clear stain from the Virgin's tear duct, treatment of fissures in her mask, and inspection of her eyelashes and tears. Upon completion of the commissioned work, Professor Arquillo indicated that the appearance of the Virgin was suitable for public display. However, it became evident that not all restoration components—specifically the eyelashes—had been properly placed prior to her being returned to public veneration. This misstep resulted in a somewhat disconcerting alteration of the Virgin's appearance, which raised concerns among Board officials. Despite these worries, a critical decision was made to place the Virgin back for worship without waiting for expert validation. Just hours before the Basilica opened to the public on Saturday the 21st, the Board faced mounting critiques, leading to a demand for Professor Arquillo's re-evaluation of the situation. The community’s response has been vehement, with numerous devotees gathering outside the Basilica in Seville to protest against the governing board, calling for their resignation due to the controversial outcome of the restoration project that many now feel has left the Virgin unrecognizable. As the governing body pledges to take corrective actions and reassess their strategies for the preservation of sacred art, the incident raises critical questions about the balance of tradition, artistry, and community trust in religious institutions. Related Sources: • Source 1 • Source 2