EU Court Upholds Fines on Major Investment Banks for Cartel Activity
The Court of Justice of the European Union, the most significant judicial body in the Union, has upheld the fines imposed by the European Commission in May 2021 against three major investment banks: Unicredit, Nomura, and UBS. While the court confirmed the penalties, it did slightly reduce the fines for Unicredit and Nomura.
The European Commission initially issued a ruling on May 20, 2021, identifying a cartel involving seven investment banks—UBS, Natixis, UniCredit, Nomura, Bank of America, Portigon, and NatWest—operating in the European government bond sector from January 2007 to November 2011. These financial institutions were found to have collaborated and exchanged sensitive information aimed at obtaining competitive advantages in the trading, issuance, or placement of government bonds.
As a consequence of their actions, the Commission levied a total fine of €371 million on Nomura, UBS, and UniCredit. Notably, no fines were implemented for Bank of America, Natixis, and NatWest due to various mitigating factors. The Commission stated that it could not impose monetary penalties on Bank of America and Natixis due to the expiration of the timeframe to enforce such penalties, while NatWest was granted immunity as it was the whistleblower that reported the cartel's activities. Additionally, Portigon received a zero fine citing its negative turnover in the last financial year.
Following the announcement, six of the seven banks involved—excluding NatWest—filed appeals with the Court of Justice, seeking to annul the Commission's conclusions or reduce their respective fines. The Court's recent decision has upheld the original penalties but adjusted the amounts for Unicredit and Nomura. The fines have been modified, with Unicredit seeing a reduction from €69.4 million to €6.5 million and Nomura's fine reduced from €129.5 million to €12.56 million. In contrast, UBS's fine of €172.3 million has been fully upheld and remains unchanged.
The court's ruling marks a significant moment in the regulation of financial institutions within Europe and underscores the ongoing commitment of the EU to combat anti-competitive practices in the financial services sector. As financial regulations continue to evolve, the importance of compliance and transparency remains critical for institutions operating within this landscape.
Related Sources: