EU Issues Fines to Apple and Meta for Violating Competition Rules Under Digital Markets Act
The European Commission has imposed substantial fines on two tech giants, Apple and Meta, for breaching regulations designed to promote fair competition and user choice. The penalties, marking the first enforcement actions under the EU's Digital Markets Act (DMA), include a €500 million fine for Apple and a €200 million penalty for Meta.
Apple faced scrutiny for restricting app developers from distributing their applications outside of the company's App Store. The Commission highlighted that such practices limited developers' ability to leverage alternative distribution channels, consequently preventing consumers from accessing potentially cheaper app offerings. The Commission has mandated that Apple rectify these restrictions within 60 days or face further penalties.
On the other hand, Meta, which owns popular platforms including Facebook and Instagram, was fined over a new consent or pay model introduced in November 2023. This model allowed EU users the choice between consenting to data usage for advertisements or paying for an ad-free service. The Commission deemed this approach non-compliant with the DMA, which aims to allow users to access similar services with reduced reliance on their personal data. Currently, the EU officials are evaluating an updated version of Meta's free personalized ad model introduced in November 2024.
These fines are significant but represent only a fraction of what tech companies could face. Under the DMA, companies can be fined up to 10% of their annual global turnover; however, the current penalties reflect considerations of the newness of the regulations and the limited timeline of the violations. To illustrate, Meta generated approximately €165 billion in revenue in 2024, while Apple’s sales totaled about €391 billion in the same fiscal year.
In a recent statement, Teresa Ribera, the Commission’s Executive Vice-President for Competition, articulated that both Apple and Meta have not met the compliance requirements established by the DMA. She underscored the importance of these regulations, asserting that all companies operating within the EU must adhere to the legal framework and respect European values.
The EU's actions have sparked controversy, particularly from the administration of former President Donald Trump, which criticized the measures as targeting successful American firms while easing the path for their European and Chinese counterparts. Meta plans to appeal to the European Court of Justice, with Joel Kaplan, Meta’s Chief Global Affairs Officer, indicating that the Commission's demands effectively impose a multibillion-dollar tariff on the company, compelling it to alter its business model significantly.
Meanwhile, Apple has reached a constructive dialogue with the Commission regarding user-choice obligations under the DMA, resulting in the conclusion of an investigation. The company has allowed European users to uninstall its pre-installed Safari web browser and Photos app, as well as simplifying the selection of alternative default web browsers.
The reaction to the fines has been mixed. While the Computer and Communications Industry Association, which represents members like Apple and Meta, criticized the enforcement actions as lacking clarity and consistency, consumer advocacy groups praised the verdict as a victory for consumer rights. Agustín Reyna, Director-General of the European Consumer Organisation, remarked that both companies had ample time for compliance but had sought to manipulate the regulations to their favor instead.
As regulatory scrutiny of tech companies intensifies globally, these recent developments serve as a critical reminder of the evolving landscape where digital market practices are increasingly under the microscope, aiming to foster a fair, competitive environment for businesses and consumers alike.
Related Sources: