EU Leaders Debate Offshore Asylum Processing Amid Rising Far-Right Influence
European leaders are bracing for potential clashes at an upcoming summit focused on the contentious topic of offshore processing for asylum seekers. This comes as the EU seeks to toughen its migration policies, driven by notable gains for far-right parties in the recent European elections and increasing pressure from member states to address migration concerns.
In a stark shift from previous stances, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has suggested the EU explore establishing return hubs in non-EU countries. This proposal is intended to facilitate the deportation of those deemed unwanted migrants or refugees. However, as leaders convened in Brussels, specific details regarding which nations would host these processing centers remained unclear.
Von der Leyen referenced the successful model implemented by Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, who has set up two asylum centers in Albania, a nation that is an EU candidate, to handle claims from individuals intercepted in international waters while attempting to reach Italy. Meloni indicated that many countries are evaluating the Albania model, highlighting a collective desire among EU leaders to pursue pragmatic solutions.
Amid ongoing crises in the Middle East, Meloni is also advocating for a reassessment of the EU's approach towards Syria, urging leaders to facilitate the voluntary and safe return of refugees.
The backdrop of this evolving migration discourse starkly contrasts with the EU's 2015 response, where then-German Chancellor Angela Merkel famously declared, 'We can manage it,' in reference to the influx of approximately 1.3 million primarily Syrian, Afghan, and Iraqi refugees. This summit follows a preliminary meeting among eleven national leaders from Italy, Denmark, and the Netherlands, which aimed at exploring innovative alternatives to existing migration policies.
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen noted a marked shift in the approach to immigration discussions, stating that raising such critical issues no longer felt like 'shouting in an empty sports hall.' She expressed concerns about public sentiment toward foreigners, particularly in light of criminal activities and radicalization among certain asylum seekers, emphasizing the emerging sentiment of limits to the assistance provided.
The Dutch government, led by Prime Minister Dick Schoof of the far-right, is reportedly contemplating a plan to deport rejected African asylum seekers to Uganda, although the legal and practical implications of such a scheme remain murky.
The European Commission has also vowed to introduce legal measures aimed at increasing deportation rates for individuals denied asylum, a process currently seeing approximately one in five being returned to their home countries. Greek Prime Minister Kyriákos Mitsotákis underscored the importance of returns, describing them as a 'missing link' in effective migration policy.
While some leaders assert the necessity of offshore processing hubs, skepticism persists. Belgium's Prime Minister Alexander De Croo warned that previous attempts at similar solutions have not yielded positive results, labeling them as costly and ineffective. Irelands Taoiseach Simon Harris echoed those concerns, criticizing Britain's previous Rwanda scheme as impractical and unproductive.
The initiative to send asylum seekers to Albania has faced criticism from Italian opposition parties, deeming it a failure despite the government's assurances for its success in alleviating pressure on overstrained reception centers like that in Lampedusa. After initial transfers, reports suggest only a small number of individuals have been relocated, raising questions about the efficacy of the Albanian agreement and the substantial financial costs associated with its implementation.
Amidst these discussions, Poland's Donald Tusk aims to garner support for redirecting asylum laws, citing threats from Belarus and Russia as tactics to destabilize the EU by pressuring its borders with migrant influxes. Thus far in 2023, Eastern EU nations have reported significant increases in migrant arrivals, while the overall count of irregular crossings across European borders has declined compared to previous years.
As this summit unfolds, it remains to be seen how EU leaders will reconcile their varying perspectives on migration and how these debates will shape the continent's policy moving forward.
Related Sources: