France's Political Turmoil: Macron Faces Tough Choices After Government Collapse
On Wednesday, France experienced a significant political upheaval as the minority government led by Prime Minister Michel Barnier fell due to a motion of no confidence, backed by parliamentarians from the left-wing New Popular Front and the far-right Rassemblement National party led by Marine Le Pen. Barnier is set to submit his resignation to President Emmanuel Macron, who appointed him just three months ago, as mandated by the French Constitution. Macron is expected to address the nation at 8 PM.
This crisis presents multiple challenges for Macron, whose options appear limited. Notably, the ongoing impasse in government means that essential legislation, such as the budget law, has yet to be approved—raising concerns over its feasibility before the year's end.
One of the critical constraints Macron faces is the inability to dissolve parliament and call for new elections. The Constitution stipulates that the National Assembly can only be dissolved 12 months after its last dissolution, which means any new elections won't happen before July 2025. Consequently, Macron must navigate the current parliament, which is fragmented into three major political blocs that have shown little intention to cooperate: his centrist alliance, the far-right RN, and the left coalition.
In light of these circumstances, Macron has four remaining strategies to consider, with the option of his resignation firmly ruled out.
Firstly, he could appoint a new prime minister, possibly from the right, in hopes of gaining greater support from the RN than Barnier could muster.
Secondly, he might seek votes from the left bloc, but this approach appears unpromising since the left has already expressed dissatisfaction over being excluded from negotiations following their legislative election victory in July.
Another option is forming a technical government composed of members who are politically independent and drawing support from various parties based on individual votes. This option, however, may face its own set of challenges given the prevailing political dynamics.
Lastly, Macron could allow Barnier’s government to continue as an interim administration focused on handling pressing affairs, while attempting to advance the budget law. However, considering Barnier’s struggles to pass this law previously, this option seems unlikely to succeed.
French media reports suggest Macron is leaning towards appointing a new prime minister, but the task of finding a candidate who can secure enough backing in the National Assembly is fraught with difficulty. A choice from the centrist alliance would likely lead to another minority government, thereby exposing it to further no-confidence motions like Barnier's.
A potential candidate under consideration could be someone like Minister of Defense Sébastien Lecornu, whose alignment with the RN could create a more stable government while facilitating budget approval with possible concessions toward the far right’s agenda.
This prospect of closer ties with the far right is precarious, as it could inadvertently bolster Le Pen's standing ahead of the upcoming presidential elections in 2027, as Macron’s term concludes.
Amidst these deliberations, meetings that followed the no-confidence vote revealed a nearly unanimous sentiment among Macron's party, Renaissance, calling for increased cooperation with the Socialist Party to mitigate the RN's influence. Yet, cooperation appears unlikely, as the Socialist Party remains part of the New Popular Front, opposing collaboration with the centrist block.
Historically, the Socialist Party has resisted the idea of distancing itself from its leftist alliance to form bonds with centrist would-be allies.
Macron's final option would be to assemble a technical government, comprising ministers free from party control, to manage day-to-day operations and implement certain reforms while courting support from various political factions when necessary. This government could aim to secure the budget law's approval while functioning until a suitable time for fresh elections.
Regardless of the approach taken, the political gridlock makes it hard to envision a budget for 2025 that would implement significant reductions in public expenditures to mitigate France's growing public debt, as suggested by Barnier's draft financial legislation. With these unfolding events, the future of French governance hangs in the balance.
Related Sources: