Germany's Border Control Measures: A Test for EU Unity and Free Movement
Germany's recent announcement to tighten controls at all its land borders, a move primarily seen as a political maneuver, poses a significant threat to the cherished principle of free movement across Europe. On Monday, the German government revealed plans to extend existing border controls with Austria, Poland, the Czech Republic, Switzerland, and now including France, Luxembourg, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Denmark, effective from September 16.
Interior Minister Nancy Faeser cited concerns over migration, Islamist terrorism, and serious crime as primary justifications for the new measures. This decision comes on the heels of concerning knife attacks attributed to asylum seekers, and right before crucial regional elections in eastern Germany, where the far-right anti-immigration Alternative for Germany (AfD) party has seen unprecedented success. Migration has emerged as a leading concern among voters, prompting concerns over the ruling coalition's stability as the elections approach.
Experts suggest the German government’s intentions are twofold: to signal to German citizens that immigrants are unwelcome and to dampen the surge in support for the AfD. While officials have indicated that stricter controls could lead to increased authority for border officials to turn away migrants, details remain sparse.
The implications of Germany's decision could extend well beyond domestic politics, potentially straining relationships among EU member states. Germany's key position within the European Union as its largest economy means that such measures risk undermining the principles on which the Schengen area was built—a system that allows passport-free travel among 25 of the 27 EU states plus Norway and Switzerland. The Schengen Agreement, established in 1985, permits temporary border checks in situations deemed emergencies or when specific threats emerge. However, increasing pressures from far-right political factions across Europe have led various nations to reimpose border checks without clear, substantiated risks.
Currently, numerous Schengen nations, including Austria, Denmark, Italy, and Poland, have reinstated border controls citing different reasons ranging from security concerns related to the conflict in Ukraine to risks of terrorism. Notably, the European Commission often permits these temporary checks, although academics warn that they challenge the foundational ideals of free movement.
Critics, such as Alberto Alemanno, a professor of European law, describe Germany's measures as a disproportionate breach of Schengen principles and question their legitimacy under EU law. Christopher Wratil from the University of Vienna expressed concern that such actions reflect a governance style buoyed by far-right rhetoric, potentially leading to a fragmentation of European unity.
The economic ramifications of reverting to stringent border controls have also triggered alarms, with a 2016 report estimating that reinstating internal border checks could cost Europe approximately €470 billion ($397 billion) in lost growth over a decade. Gerald Knaus from the European Stability Initiative argued that effective internal border control measures would imply a fundamental rework of Schengen, exacerbating relations with neighboring countries unwilling to cooperate.
As major reforms to the EU's asylum and migration laws take effect in 2026, questions arise about whether Germany's heavy-handed approach could ignite further tensions within the bloc. Austria has openly rejected any responsibility to take back migrants rejected at the German border, echoing sentiments from Poland's Prime Minister Donald Tusk, who labeled Germany's decision as 'unacceptable.'
As the situation develops, it remains to be seen how Germany's approach will be received by its neighbors and what implications it carries for the unity of the EU. This episode underscores the fragility of the Schengen Agreement and poses challenging questions about the future of migration policy within Europe.
Related Sources: