Germany's Reintroduction of Border Checks: Security Measures or Political Maneuver?
Germany is set to reintroduce temporary checks at all nine of its land borders starting Monday, a decision that has sparked criticism from several European partners while receiving support from far-right factions within the country. The coalition government in Berlin announced that the existing checks along borders with Austria, Poland, the Czech Republic, and Switzerland would be expanded to include France, Luxembourg, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Denmark.
This policy shift has been linked to a recent string of violent knife attacks where suspects were reportedly asylum seekers and the rising popularity of the far-right Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) party in eastern state elections. Interior Minister Nancy Faeser justified the border checks as necessary measures to reduce migration and mitigate threats related to Islamist terrorism and serious crime. However, critics argue that this approach is politically motivated and likely to yield limited results.
The reintroduction of checks raises concerns about the integrity of Europe’s Schengen zone, known for facilitating passport-free travel across 25 EU nations and four others, including Switzerland and Norway. Although temporary border checks are permissible under exceptional circumstances to address security concerns, several nations already impose such measures, citing heightened terror threats or pressure on their asylum systems.
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk was among the first leaders to publicly criticize Germany's decision, deeming it unacceptable from Poland’s perspective. He expressed the need for enhanced cooperation between EU nations to bolster the EU's external borders, rather than tightening internal controls. Similarly, Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis cautioned against creating a precedent for ad hoc border control measures that could harm one of the EU's foundational achievements.
In contrast, some leaders welcomed Germany’s move. Geert Wilders, head of the Dutch Freedom Party, called it a "great idea," while Hungary’s Prime Minister, Viktor Orbán, expressed support on social media. Marine Le Pen of France’s National Rally noted her party had proposed similar border systems in the past, and now Germany's action legitimizes that discussion. Giorgia Meloni of Italy's Brothers of Italy party also praised the decision, highlighting a growing trend in Europe towards stringent border controls.
Chancellor Olaf Scholz, facing political pressure domestically as the AfD gains traction in the polls, defended the decision as essential even though it complicates Germany's relations with its neighbors. With critical regional elections approaching, including one in Brandenburg where the AfD is expected to perform strongly, the government maintains that the increased checks are necessary.
Although the specific impacts of these border checks remain uncertain, Berlin has emphasized its commitment to coordinate with neighboring countries to minimize disruption in everyday life across border regions. The German interior ministry stated that the checks, intended to last for an initial six months, would largely consist of random inspections or targeting particular vehicles based on police intelligence.
While freight industry representatives do not anticipate significant delays, associations representing cross-border workers are closely monitoring the situation, wary of how these checks might affect their operations. Analysts predict that tensions with neighboring countries may escalate if the checks pave the way for returning asylum seekers to their entry points, further complicating Germany's role in the EU's asylum framework.
As Germany grapples with these challenging dynamics, the reintroduction of border checks underscores the complexities of balancing national security and maintaining the foundational principles of the EU, which prides itself on the abolishment of internal borders.
Related Sources: