Germany's Strategic Shift: A New Leadership Path in the EU
Germany has historically been regarded as the backbone of the European Union—a pivotal and prosperous nation. However, in recent years, Berlin's leadership has been overshadowed by internal strife within its coalition government that has led to indecision and inconsistent policies. Chancellor Olaf Scholz's so-called ‘cool relationship’ with French President Emmanuel Macron has hindered the once-powerful Franco-German partnership that is essential for EU cohesion. Tensions with Poland over issues like European air defense and past grievances have further complicated Germany's standing in Europe.
Friedrich Merz, poised to become Germany's next chancellor, acknowledges the urgent need for a revitalized German leadership within Europe. As emphasized by Jana Puglierin, head of the Berlin office at the European Council on Foreign Relations, establishing a cohesive voice in Brussels is imperative. The pressure is mounting for Berlin to take decisive action, particularly in regard to military aid for Ukraine, as the rest of Europe looks to Germany for increased support.
Merz has notably warned against appeasement toward Russia; he has committed to sending long-range Taurus cruise missiles to Ukraine—something previously denied under Scholz’s leadership. Furthermore, discussions surrounding deploying German troops to Ukraine have stirred controversy, with Scholz labeling such talks as 'premature.'
There is a consensus among mainstream German political factions that supporting Ukraine remains critical, yet addressing how to fund this support could complicate coalition negotiations—potentially stalling aid deployment.
As Germany heads into the upcoming NATO summit in June, demands for increased defense spending are expected to rise. A push to elevate military expenditure to at least 3% of GDP may necessitate reforming Germany's existing debt brake, which restricts annual borrowing to 0.35% of GDP. Additionally, many EU member states are urging Berlin to reconsider its stand against pan-European defense borrowing, also known as eurobonds. Notably, while Merz has traditionally favored fiscally conservative policies, he has shown a degree of receptiveness toward these suggestions, although their adoption is not guaranteed.
As leader of the center-right party, Merz is likely to moderate more extreme proposals from his campaign, such as implementing stringent border controls that could strain relationships with neighboring countries, including Poland. Previous controls initiated by Scholz's administration had already been criticized by Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, showcasing the delicate balance of maintaining cordial relations in a region still sensitive to past tensions.
With Merz's expected leadership style leaning toward a more assertive approach than that of Scholz, his ability to manage relations with both Tusk and Macron is anticipated to improve, potentially reinstating stronger Franco-German coordination in the EU framework. However, challenges loomed as the complexities of dealing with US politics arise, particularly with the unpredictable nature of Donald Trump’s influence on transatlantic relations. The recent encounter between Trump and far-right European leaders serves as a reminder of the shifting dynamics that could put pressure on longstanding alliances.
As Germany contemplates its role in a changing global landscape, Merz is navigating a path laden with expectation. His leadership will have to balance internal party pressures with the need for assertiveness in international responsibilities, all while redefining Germany's relationship with the EU, the United States, and the challenges presented by conflicts like that in Ukraine. The coming months will be crucial in determining whether Germany can regain its status as the EU's pivotal player in advocating for unity and stability across the continent.
Related Sources: