Israeli Military Admits Major Failures in Hamas Attack, Pressures Netanyahu
The Israeli military has publicly acknowledged its catastrophic misjudgment regarding the intentions and capabilities of Hamas leading up to the deadly attack on October 7, 2023. This admission, documented in an investigation released on Thursday, underscores the Israel Defense Forces' (IDF) failure to protect civilians during what has been described as the deadliest assault in Israeli history.
The report highlights that the IDF underestimated Hamas' strength and was ill-prepared for the assault, which involved thousands of well-armed militants executing a coordinated strike during a significant Jewish holiday. The shocking revelation has intensified calls for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to initiate a broader inquiry into the political decision-making processes that preceded the incident, which has since escalated into a protracted 16-month conflict in Gaza.
Amidst growing scrutiny, a senior Israeli army official lamented, "October 7 was a complete failure. Too many civilians died that day, asking themselves, ‘Where was the IDF?’" This sentiment reflects the deep frustrations among the Israeli populace and military alike. Following the investigation's release, Lieutenant General Herzi Halevi, the IDF's chief of staff, publicly accepted responsibility for the failures and expressed his commitment to accountability within the military hierarchy.
The attack resulted in approximately 1,200 fatalities, predominantly civilians, and led to the abduction of 251 individuals by Hamas. In the ensuing conflict, the Hamas-run health ministry reported that around 48,000 people have been killed in Gaza, although it does not specify whether these casualties include civilians or combatants.
The investigation revealed that a dangerous misconception held by Israeli decision-makers was that Hamas, which seized control of Gaza in 2007, was more focused on governance than military confrontation with Israel. As a result, critical preventive actions that could have thwarted the attack were neglected. Intelligence assessments pointed out that late Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar had been orchestrating plans for the attack since at least 2017.
While the report refrained from attributing blame to specific soldiers or officers, it is anticipated to catalyze significant changes within the military structure, including potential resignations and firings. This follows a backdrop of high-profile departures, with several senior officers, including the former head of military intelligence, stepping down amid the fallout from the attack.
Public sentiment in Israel points toward broader failures, extending beyond the military to the political leadership of Netanyahu. Many citizens perceive that his strategy of deterrence and containment, which involved enabling financial support to Gaza from Qatar and undermining Hamas' main rival, the Palestinian Authority, has led to dangerous vulnerabilities.
Despite mounting pressure, Netanyahu's administration has resisted calls for an inquiry into the government's role, arguing that such investigations should wait until the conflict is resolved. As Israel and Hamas continue negotiations on the next phases of a ceasefire, the potential consequences of the military's findings loom large over Netanyahu's leadership and future decisions regarding defense and policy in the region.
Related Sources: