Iwao Hakamada Acquitted: A Pivotal Moment in Japan's Justice System
On Thursday, a court in Shizuoka, central Japan, acquitted Iwao Hakamada of all charges, marking a profound moment in the country's judicial history. Hakamada, who is now 88 years old, was sentenced to death in 1980 for the 1966 murder of his employer’s family, a crime he has consistently denied committing. His case is notable not only for its dramatic circumstances but also for the nearly fifty years he spent imprisoned, making him the longest-serving death row inmate in the world, if counting from his initial arrest in 1968.
The events leading to Hakamada's conviction began on June 30, 1966, when the bodies of his employer, his wife, and their two children were discovered in their home in Shizuoka. After an initial interrogation and subsequent release, Hakamada was rearrested about a month later, based on circumstantial evidence including traces of gasoline and blood found on his pajamas. He was accused of murdering the family, setting fire to their house, and stealing money.
During prolonged interrogations, Hakamada confessed to the crimes, but later claimed that he had been subjected to physical abuse and coercion by police. Despite initially pleading not guilty, he was convicted of murder and arson in 1968, and his conviction was upheld through a series of appeals, culminating in a 1980 ruling by the Japanese Supreme Court.
The conviction was controversial, laden with inconsistencies and a lack of investigation into other potential suspects. In 1967, just over a year after the murders, blood-stained clothing was discovered at Hakamada’s workplace, which the prosecution insisted belonged to the murderer. Hakamada maintained his innocence throughout his long incarceration, focusing on the coerced confession and challenging the prosecution's evidence.
In an important turn of events, in 2008, Hakamada's legal team gained access to DNA testing on the blood found on the clothes. The results showed that the blood did not match Hakamada or any of the victims, casting significant doubt on the evidence used to convict him. Consequently, he was released in 2014 while awaiting a new trial, as a judge ruled that the evidence against him was unreliable.
However, the legal battle did not end there. In 2018, the Tokyo High Court declared the DNA evidence inadmissible, leading the case to the Supreme Court, which took the matter up again in 2020. Ultimately, the Supreme Court instructed the Tokyo High Court to determine whether Hakamada's death sentence was valid or if a new trial was warranted, focusing on the evidence that had brought about his conviction.
This past Thursday, the Shizuoka court made the landmark decision, declaring Hakamada innocent and stating that the investigators had fabricated evidence against him. Due to health concerns, Hakamada did not attend the court session, but hundreds gathered outside to celebrate the verdict, greeting the news with heartfelt enthusiasm, shouting "banzai," which translates to "hooray" in Japanese.
Although Hakamada's acquittal represents a significant moment in Japan, it remains the fifth death sentence to be overturned due to a new trial since the country resumed capital punishment post-World War II. There is precedent for the prosecution to appeal the ruling, leaving the chances for the final resolution of Hakamada's case uncertain.
The toll of over four decades behind bars—often in conditions that could have led to his execution on short notice—has taken a severe toll on Hakamada's physical and mental health. His sister, Hideko Hakamada, who has been a constant supporter throughout this tumultuous journey, expressed joy at the court's decision. As she celebrated outside the courthouse alongside dozens of supporters and journalists, the wider implications of this case for Japan's judicial system, particularly concerning the death penalty, were clear.
Documentaries and films have chronicled Hakamada's plight, highlighting the case's significant national and international implications. As discussions about the legitimacy and application of the death penalty in Japan resurface, Iwao Hakamada’s story remains a powerful narrative urging reform and justice within a legal system that has grappled with serious questions of fairness and reliability.
Related Sources: