Marine Le Pen's Conviction and the Rise of Jordan Bardella: The Future of France's National Rally
The verdict is in: the National Rally (NR) and its leader, Marine Le Pen, have been found guilty of employing fictitious European Parliament assistants between 2004 and 2016. This fraudulent scheme enabled the misappropriation of around €29 million in European funds, and as a result, Le Pen has been barred from holding public office for five years. But could this mark the end for the National Rally? Highly unlikely, as the party's strategy under Le Pen is rooted in unpredictability and resilience.
During the trial, Le Pen chose to remain silent in response to the allegations—a tactic dismissed by some outlets as indicative of a weak defense. However, such silence reflects a long-standing strategy that deliberately avoids conventional responses, instead adopting an unpredictable approach that has served the party well.
The origins of this strategy date back to 2011 when Le Pen initiated the ‘dedemonisation’ process of the NR. This was not merely about reshaping the party's public perception; it was also aimed at severing connections with the extremist legacy of her family. Through rebranding the Front National into the National Rally, she charted a new path for the party's future.
This transition involved purging party members who endorsed the Vichy regime, even leading to the expulsion of her own father, Jean-Marie Le Pen. By sidelining him, she demonstrated a readiness to make significant sacrifices for the sake of her vision. Now, Le Pen may face another critical juncture where she must consider sacrificing her political career to pave the way for the NR's rising star, Jordan Bardella.
At just 29 years old, Bardella represents a generational shift that connects with younger voters, particularly men. His adept use of social media platforms like TikTok has energized the party's base and illustrates the evolving landscape of far-right organizing in the digital realm.
Current opinion polls indicate that the NR enjoys growing support, and with Marine Le Pen's recent legal troubles, Bardella may hold an advantageous position. His potential rise mirrors political strategies seen in other countries, where legal challenges faced by leaders have been reframed as unjust persecution, igniting further support among their bases.
A clear parallel can be drawn with Donald Trump, who downplayed his legal challenges as politically motivated after the Capitol attack. Similarly, regarding Le Pen's conviction, Trump commented it was a substantial issue—echoing a familiar narrative of unjust political warfare, a theme we observe not only in France but across Europe.
In Romania, the far-right populist Călin Georgescu faced a ruling blocking him from the presidential race, yet his supporters fervently rallied around another far-right figure, George Simion, who currently leads in the polls. This trajectory of reinforcement among far-right factions suggests a growing resilience rather than deterioration in the face of setbacks. Silvio Berlusconi, the former Italian Prime Minister, is a prime example of this. Despite his tumultuous legal history, he managed to overturn convictions and reshape his narrative, framing charges against him as political in nature.
Le Pen, consistent with this pattern, has insisted that her prosecution is a political maneuver and an affront to democracy. Such rhetoric is characteristic of far-right movements; unfavorable court decisions are viewed as politically motivated conspiracies, while victories are celebrated as sanctities of democracy.
The question now is how to address this troubling playbook. First and foremost, we must reject the narrative that Le Pen's conviction is a political attack, especially within the left. Upholding dignity in these challenging democratic times requires acknowledging that courts serve to deliver justice—no individual is above the law.
Moreover, Bardella's rapid ascent in popularity calls for a decisive response from the French left, the only political force capable of mounting a robust challenge to the ideologies of hate, economic isolation, and white supremacy. The NR's long-term strategy positions Bardella at the forefront, a move that could resonate deeply with voters following Le Pen’s legal issues.
This serves as a clarion call for the left, particularly for Jean-Luc Mélenchon and France Unbowed. The party must rejuvenate, diversify its ranks, and cultivate emerging talent appealing to younger demographics, similar to strategies employed by Die Linke in Germany. This is essential not just for the left’s survival but also for containing the far-right’s influential revamp within Europe after decades of relative retreat since World War II.
It is increasingly evident that the lines between global far-right movements are blurring, with their tactics evolving in tandem. As echoed in Elon Musk's public support for Le Pen, recognizing and confronting this challenge is vital for democracies. There is a pressing need for unparalleled unity against the resurgent threat of the far-right before it is too late.
Related Sources: