Netanyahu's Mixed Emotions: The Implications of Trump's Election Win for Israel
Benjamin Netanyahu's tone following the election of Donald Trump was nearly triumphant. Speaking on the evening of November 6, 2024, he was among the first to congratulate the newly elected President of the United States. The warmth of their conversation, recounted in an official press release, reflected an eagerness to collaborate on Israel's security and address the Iranian threat—a conversation that also took place amid heightened sensitivities following the events of October 7, 2023, when Israel faced a devastating terrorist attack.
Netanyahu notably hailed Trump's victory as the greatest comeback in political history, perhaps drawing parallels to his own resilience in Israeli politics, where he has repeatedly triumphed despite legal challenges and coalition fissures. However, the question lingers: is Netanyahu genuinely as elated as he appears, or is there a layer of uncertainty beneath the surface?
His strained relationship with the Biden administration is well-documented, and historical tensions with Trump, particularly after Netanyahu's 2020 congratulatory message to Joe Biden, add complexity to Netanyahu's public declarations of support for the new president. Trump has been openly critical of Netanyahu's actions during that period, expressing confusion and disappointment over the Israeli leader's failure to remain neutral until the election concluded.
In the wake of the October 7 attacks, Trump took to social media to claim that such an attack would never have happened under his administration, implying his belief that Netanyahu's leadership should be called into question. Now, despite a shared history of cooperation, the landscape has shifted. While Trump has been favorable to Israel—moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, recognizing Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights, and proposing a controversial peace plan—his motivations remain primarily focused on America First.
On the other hand, Trump's historical reluctance to commit U.S. resources or personnel for foreign engagements raises concerns about his priorities. Will he genuinely prioritize Israeli hostages in Gaza, or will his administration turn a blind eye as long as political optics serve his interests? If Trump pushes Netanyahu to end military operations in Gaza or to accept terms regarding Palestinian statehood in exchange for a broader regional peace involving Saudi Arabia, the Israeli Prime Minister might find himself in an untenable position that could threaten his political alliance.
Despite Netanyahu's jubilation over Trump's election, the coming months may reveal a more complicated reality, one where Netanyahu’s hopes are tempered by the geopolitical and domestic pressures he faces. How this dynamic unfolds could significantly shape the future of Israeli policy and the broader Middle East. Only time will tell how Netanyahu navigates the intricate dance of diplomacy with a potentially unpredictable partner in Donald Trump.
Related Sources: