Revisiting Spain's Policies on ETA Prisoners: Reform or Political Tactics?
The recent legal reforms involving sentences for ETA prisoners have ignited a complex debate in Spanish politics. Unlike reductions in sentences, the current reforms, which are rooted in applying standard laws to terrorists, are being viewed as a form of normalizing the treatment of ETA inmates as the country moves away from exceptional measures put in place during decades of violence. This shift in approach has been gradual and rooted in conversations dating back six years between the Socialist Party (PSOE) and the Basque independentist party EH Bildu.
One of the key improvements in this reform is the elimination of the dispersion of ETA prisoners, which was officially declared over in March 2023. This meant that 377 ETA inmates were transferred to prisons within the Basque Country—efforts that sought to return these individuals closer to their communities. The reform currently under discussion aims to amend previous legislation that excluded certain prisoners from the European Union’s community criminal law, essentially applying the same legal treatment to ETA prisoners as that applied to others.
The controversial aspect of this reform is not about granting additional benefits, but rather ensuring that ETA inmates serve their maximum 30-year sentences without the exceptional conditions that once surrounded them. Supporters in the PSOE argue that since the definitive end of violence in 2011, a new era of peace and political normalization has emerged, paving the way for such reforms.
Yet, despite the progress, there are still significant tensions within Spanish politics surrounding these changes. The opposition—particularly the Popular Party (PP)—has employed heated rhetoric against Pedro Sánchez, accusing him of compromising with ETA and presenting a narrative that these reforms could undermine the fight against terrorism. Critics have expressed fears that the legal amendments, especially given their support from parties like Vox, could be misconstrued as a weakening of Spain's stance against terrorism.
As lawmakers work through the complexities of this legislation, the lines between legal practice, political strategy, and societal response continue to blur. In essence, this reform not only addresses the issue of how ETA prisoners are treated under Spanish law but also raises questions about the legacy of political violence in Spain and the ongoing challenge of reconciliation in a society still grappling with its past.
Related Sources: