Schengen Anniversary Marks Tensions: Germany Faces Criticism Over Border Controls
During the celebrations for the 40th anniversary of the Schengen Agreement, which championed the idea of borderless travel across Europe, a palpable tension emerged as European partner nations renewed their criticism of Germany's ongoing border controls. Poland's Interior Minister Tomasz Siemoniak, speaking at a gathering in the Luxembourg border town of Schengen, expressed a desire to convince Germany that maintaining open borders is fundamentally in its own interest as well as that of the European Union.
Siemoniak remarked that despite the significance of the anniversary, the current situation does not feel celebratory. "It has been 40 years, but I wouldn't describe it as a celebration,” he stated. Since the signing of the Schengen Agreement on June 14, 1985, by Germany, France, Luxembourg, Belgium, and the Netherlands, which aimed to dismantle border controls progressively, the Schengen Area has grown to include 29 countries and nearly 420 million inhabitants.
Yet, just a short distance from the anniversary celebrations, Germany has been reinforcing its border controls. This move has drawn criticism from various partner nations. After the new German government took office, Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt of the Christian Social Union requested more intensive border checks. This policy includes a stipulation that asylum seekers can also be turned away at the border, a practice the federal government has continued even after an urgent ruling by the Berlin Administrative Court.
At the Luxembourg meeting, Interior Minister Léon Gloden reported that Dobrindt had assured him of plans to move these border controls inland, though he provided no specific timeline for this relocation. Gloden cautioned that a delay could lead to European citizens facing unexpected border checks, potentially leading to legal challenges in the European Court of Justice.
The sentiments expressed during this anniversary reflect a broader concern for the integrity of the Schengen Area. The tension between maintaining national security and the ideals of free movement continues to test the bonds between EU member states. The upcoming discussions among European leaders will be decisive in realigning policies to uphold the foundational tenets of the Schengen Agreement while addressing the various security concerns that have prompted these controls in the first place.
Related Sources: