Systemic Failures Exposed in Greece's Deadly Train Disaster Report
A comprehensive report on Greece's deadliest train disaster, which resulted in the tragic loss of 57 lives on February 28, 2023, was released on Thursday. This 180-page document highlights profound systemic safety failures and the alarming destruction of crucial evidence shortly after the crash. The report was presented at the Journalists Union of Athens Daily Newspapers (ESIEA) by officials from the Hellenic Aviation and Railway Safety Investigation Agency (HARSIA), along with members of the Investigation Committee and executives from the European Union Agency for Railways (ERA) including Bart Accou and Fabrizio Carpinelli.
HARSIA President Christos Papadimitriou underscored that the accident scene was inadequately secured, leading to the loss of essential evidence. 'The destruction of data within three days should never have happened. This must not be repeated,' stated investigator Kostas Kapetanidis. In a solemn moment before the report unveiling, officials observed a minute of silence in honor of the tragedy's victims.
Investigators pointed to a possible unidentified fuel that exacerbated the fireball after the collision, suggesting it may have intensified the flames and contributed to the fatalities of five to seven victims due to fire-related injuries. The catastrophic incident occurred when a passenger train, carrying 353 individuals from Athens to Thessaloniki, collided with a freight train traveling from Neoi Poroi to Larissa.
The investigation attributed the crash principally to a critical human error; the stationmaster in Larissa mistakenly set the tracks. This mismanagement directed the passenger train onto the same track as the inbound freight train. The report also noted that an outdated communication system and the stationmaster's lack of experience played significant roles in the oversight. A lack of automated safety mechanisms that might have averted this error was identified as a key contributing factor.
Other systemic issues highlighted included poor maintenance practices, insufficient staffing, and obsolete infrastructure. A long-delayed contract for automatic signaling systems—known as Contract 717—was identified as a crucial failure contributing to the disaster.
The report further criticized Hellenic Train for providing inadequate safety training for train drivers, particularly concerning communication protocols. The open-channel radio system employed by Greek railways restricts direct, uninterrupted communication between stationmasters and train operators, thereby elevating the risks involved. Additionally, the absence of a national accident investigation body during that period meant that lessons from previous railway incidents were not thoroughly analyzed or learned.
In summation, investigators concluded that every aspect of the railway system faltered on the night of the accident. 'Everything went wrong,' stated Papadimitriou. While it remains unclear if these failures were due to intentional negligence or mere oversights, the report starkly illustrates a series of preventable errors that led to one of Greece's darkest transportation tragedies.
Related Sources: