The Conclave: A Tumultuous Search for Pope Francis's Successor
As the sun set behind St. Peter's Basilica on Wednesday, the anticipation in the crowd mounted. The absence of smoke from the Sistine Chapel chimney left many speculating about the delayed first vote of the conclave. Rumors ranged from a malfunctioning stove to a potential medical emergency, with some suggesting disagreements among the cardinals may have contributed to the hold-up. The truth, however, is perhaps simpler: the voting commenced late, and record participation - 133 cardinal electors, many of whom were newcomers - inevitably slowed the process.
While meaningful debate may be underway among the cardinals, it likely occurs outside the hallowed walls of the Sistine Chapel. The chapel, reserved strictly for the voting and counting process, fosters an environment of quiet reflection, with conversations and lobbying happening in-between sessions. The discussions about the next pope and the Roman Catholic Church's future intensified following Pope Francis's death, but frameworks for these conversations began long before.
Various factions are vying for influence in this conclave, primarily categorized into progressives, conservatives, unifiers, and an influential Italian contingent. Key players in this lobbying endeavor include both voting and non-voting cardinals. With around 80 of the 133 cardinal electors having never participated in a conclave prior—21 of whom were appointed only months before Francis's passing—there are differing opinions on the future direction of the Church.
Progressives advocate for the preservation and extension of Pope Francis's legacy, with a pressing agenda that tackles inequality, marginalization, climate change, and migration. They are pushing for an increase in the representation of lay people, especially women, in Vatican positions, a focus on the Global South—the region where the Church is experiencing substantial growth—and a more humble, 'poor Church for the poor' rather than one steeped in tradition and opulence. Prominent among this group are Jean-Claude Hollerich from Luxembourg, Timothy Radcliffe from the UK, and Michael Czerny from Canada—individuals noted for their progressive ideals yet not leading the pack as papabile candidates.
Cardinal Luis Tagle from the Philippines, often described as 'Asian Francis' due to his charisma and relatable persona, is among the names being floated by progressives. However, a controversial video of him singing John Lennon's 'Imagine' has raised doubts about his candidacy among conservative factions. Another contender is Italian Matteo Zuppi, a 69-year-old known for his outreach to the marginalized, including his welcome to gay Catholics.
In stark contrast, traditionalist conservatives are represented by figures like Raymond Burke, a US bishop aligned with Donald Trump, and Gerhard Müller, who was dismissed by Francis from the Vatican’s doctrinal office. Their agenda seeks to reverse Francis's reforms, reinstating orthodox teachings. Candidates aligned with such values include Péter Erdő, a Hungarian archbishop closely tied to the right-wing government, and Robert Sarah from Guinea, who has expressed strong opposition to the previous pontiff's priorities.
Some cardinals are promoting the idea of a pope capable of unifying the church's varied factions, avoiding the pitfalls of further alienation. However, many progressives view this call for unity as a veneer for reintegrating critics of Francis's tenure. A name that emerges as a potential unifying figure is Pietro Parolin, the Italian cardinal and Vatican diplomat, though his perceived lack of charisma could pose a challenge.
Another intriguing subgroup consists of cardinals wishing for a pope from Italy, which has not seen representation in this role for 47 years. The last Italian pope held office until 1978, making this a significant desire for an institution that previously maintained an Italian leadership for 455 consecutive years. Perspective candidate Pierbattista Pizzaballa, currently the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, could potentially bridge the desire for an Italian figure as well as a global representative. However, his relative youth may not sit well with some who prefer a papal leadership that spans decades.
Ultimately, the inner workings of the conclave remain shrouded behind the locked doors of the Sistine Chapel, leaving the fate of the papacy unknown. The extent to which the new pope's character and priorities will evolve remains uncertain as he steps out onto the balcony of St. Peter's Basilica, facing the world as a representative of the divine to 1.4 billion followers. This duality of responsibility may well shape him as much as he shapes the future of the church itself.
Related Sources: