The Controversy of Firefighting in Los Angeles: Private Teams and Incarcerated Workers
In response to the ongoing wildfires since Tuesday, Los Angeles has turned to a combination of public and private firefighting resources, utilizing not only regular firefighters but also private teams that incur costs of thousands of dollars each day. Alongside these efforts, over 900 incarcerated individuals are assisting in various firefighting roles, sparking debate over the ethics of such practices.
According to a report by the New York Times, private firefighters have become a sought-after resource in affluent and high-risk communities across Southern California. Data from Deborah Miley, the director of the National Wildfire Suppression Association, reveals that private firefighters account for nearly 45 percent of all firefighters currently available in the United States. This trend has emerged as private companies have established contracts with governments since the 1980s, supplementing local teams funded by public resources. Currently, there are about 250 private companies under federal contract, with many more hired directly by insurance firms offering wildfire protection policies to homeowners.
The financial implications of hiring private firefighting teams are significant. A small, two-person crew can cost up to $3,000 a day, while larger teams consisting of 20 members may run up to $10,000 daily. These teams often engage in preemptive efforts to protect properties, employing strategies such as removing vegetation, spreading fire retardant, and sealing air vents. David Torgerson, founder of Wildfire Defense Systems, explains their approach: "We make the property safe so that the fire can pass over it."
The increasing frequency and intensity of wildfires have driven up the demand for private firefighting services. To address the growing sector, California passed a regulatory law in 2018 mandating private firefighters to coordinate with public agencies and restricting them from using public emergency markings and sirens.
A key issue surrounding the use of private firefighting teams involves their access to water resources, particularly during critical fire conditions when public water can become scarce. Private firefighters claim they come equipped with water trucks capable of carrying hundreds of gallons, with plans to refill from local bodies of water or even residents' swimming pools in urban areas.
However, criticisms abound regarding the presence of private firefighters on the scene. Brian Rice, president of the California Professional Firefighters, representing 35,000 firefighters, emphasizes that such teams do not represent a valuable resource in urban settings, expressing concerns over their training and capabilities.
Moreover, the ability for wealthy residents to hire private firefighters has raised profound class issues, highlighting disparities in access to fire protection. This was evident when a businessman publicly sought firefighters for his home, offering to pay any amount, which led to backlash and negative comments online.
Simultaneously, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) reported that over 900 incarcerated individuals are actively working to assist public emergency personnel in Los Angeles. While this practice has a long-standing history, critics argue that it exploits incarcerated individuals, often underpaying them compared to the state's minimum wage.
Incarcerated workers are primarily assigned preventive and support tasks, such as clearing vegetation. However, despite their efforts, they face significant risks. A 2022 report from the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) indicates that during the five years preceding the report, four incarcerated firefighters lost their lives while performing duties, with many more suffering injuries.
Incarcerated workers reportedly earn between $580 and $1,024 a day, which is markedly lower than California’s $16.50 minimum wage. While working on firefighting crews results in reduced sentences (two days off for each day worked), their future opportunities to work in similar roles post-release remain bleak due to their criminal records.
The growing concern for incarcerated firefighters has not gone unnoticed. The Anti-Recidivism Coalition, a nonprofit advocating for ex-detainees and criminal justice reform, has launched a fundraiser to support California’s prison firefighting crews, managing to raise over $40,000 to date. As the wildfires continue to ravage the Los Angeles area, the reliance on both private firefighting teams and incarcerated workers presents a complex and contentious landscape that intertwines emergency response, economic disparities, and the ongoing conversation about criminal justice reform.
Related Sources: