The Future of Hamas After Yahya Sinwar's Death: Leadership Changes and Strategic Implications
The death of Yahya Sinwar, a key figure in Hamas and its military chief, marks a significant turning point in the ongoing conflict between Israel and the Palestinian group following the invasion of the Gaza Strip after October 7, 2023. Sinwar's demise presents a challenge for Hamas, yet experts suggest that the organization is unlikely to disband as it is a resilient political and military entity that has survived the assassinations of numerous leaders over the years.
As reported by the Washington Post, while Sinwar's death is a serious setback for Hamas, it does not spell the end of the movement nor will it halt the violence in the region. Mkhaimar Abusada, a political science professor at Al-Azhar University in Gaza, posits that Hamas views itself as a national liberation movement, dedicated to resisting Israeli occupation; thus, if one leader is lost, another will step in to continue the fight.
Speculation regarding Sinwar's successor has begun, with many analysts pointing towards his brother, Mohammed, as a potential candidate for the military leadership position in Gaza. However, experts express skepticism about Mohammed's ability to assume the role of a political leader, a position that Yahya effectively held alongside his military responsibilities after the assassination of Ismail Haniyeh in July.
The appointment of Sinwar’s successor may not be formally announced for security purposes, leaving the door open for the Shura Council—Hamas's secret advisory body composed of its members from various regions—to decide the future leadership structure. This could see a leader emerge from abroad, with Khaled Meshal, Hamas’s former leader who directed operations from exile, being a notable possibility. Meshal has evaded multiple assassination attempts and has a history of navigating Hamas leadership from various countries, including his current base in Doha, Qatar.
Khalil al Hayya, another prominent Hamas figure and Sinwar's deputy, remains in Qatar as well. Having been part of Hamas's leadership for decades, al Hayya survived an assassination attempt in 2007. His longstanding presence in leadership positions adds to the pool of potential successors, but it’s uncertain if he possesses the necessary political clout akin to Sinwar.
From an Israeli perspective, Michael Milshtein, a former army official, notes that Hamas leaders operating from exile tend to be more flexible in negotiations. This possibility opens avenues for countries like Qatar and Egypt to leverage their influence to push Hamas toward a ceasefire, particularly amid ongoing hostilities.
Mousa Abu Marzouk, another key Hamas figure, has a history of political engagement in the United States and the United Arab Emirates, helping to shape the Palestinian cause from these regions. His experiences provide another layer of complexity, as he has navigated the challenges of being implicated in terrorism-related accusations.
Muhammad Deif, the commander of Hamas's military wing, the Qassam Brigades, remains an integral part of the organization. Allegations suggest he was involved in planning the October 7 attacks that heightened tensions dramatically. His survival after previous assassination attempts by Israel symbolizes Hamas's endurance amidst strategic upheavals.
As the aftermath of Sinwar's death unfolds, Hamas faces a critical juncture. The organization’s ability to maintain operational continuity and political coherence while adapting to evolving leadership dynamics will be instrumental in shaping the conflict’s trajectory in the coming months. While the loss of significant leadership is a blow to Hamas, its history of resilience suggests that it will strive to reorganize and continue its fight against Israeli operations.
Related Sources: