The Guardian and Others Bid Farewell to X: A Significant Shift in Social Media Landscape
On Wednesday, the UK’s prominent newspaper, The Guardian, announced its decision to stop using its accounts on the social network X (formerly Twitter). This decision comes as a reaction to the perceived negative impact of the platform, particularly under the ownership of billionaire Elon Musk. The Guardian's leadership indicated that the harmful content proliferating on X, which includes violent, racist narratives and conspiracy theories, outweighed any benefits of maintaining a presence on the platform.
The timing of The Guardian's announcement coincided with the revelation of Musk's involvement in the future government of Donald Trump, where he is expected to play a significant role in cutting federal agency expenses. Musk's companies maintain extensive contracts with the U.S. government, and he has long advocated for a drastic reduction in regulations pertaining to various sectors, including environmental protections and telecommunications.
Commentators have pointed out that since acquiring the platform in 2022, Musk has transformed X into what many view as a propaganda vehicle for himself and the political right. This transition is marked by a lax approach to content moderation, leading to the viral dissemination of extremist ideologies, including posts that glorify Hitler and propagate transphobic and supremacist theories.
In its formal announcement, The Guardian suggested that its decision to exit X was not a hasty one. Months of concern over the platform's promotion of disturbing content, coupled with the current U.S. presidential election cycle, has led the newspaper to label X as a 'toxic media platform,' wherein Musk’s influence has notably shaped the political dialogue.
Readers can still share articles from The Guardian via their personal accounts, but the site's official profiles have been marked as archived. In a similar vein, the Spanish newspaper La Vanguardia also declared it would cease its operations on X, citing the rampant spread of hate toward ethnic minorities and various forms of discrimination prevalent on the platform.
The exodus extends beyond newspapers to include notable personalities. U.S. journalist Don Lemon, who boasts over 15 million followers, decided to leave X after the platform altered its terms of service, raising concerns about legal disputes favoring conservative legislation. Lemon had previously been in negotiations to host a show on X but later pursued legal action against Musk for breach of contract.
Actress Jamie Lee Curtis also deactivated her X account, sharing her decision on Instagram with a quote reflecting her desire for acceptance and change. Similarly, acclaimed Mexican director Guillermo del Toro announced a shift to Bluesky, a competing platform gaining momentum as disenchanted users flee X. Reports suggest that at least 100,000 users in the U.S. alone deactivated their accounts within days of the recent elections, with Bluesky welcoming millions of new subscribers since then.
This trend away from X isn't novel. Earlier this year, NPR discontinued its presence on the platform after being labeled as 'state-affiliated media,' a designation that NPR contested vehemently, arguing it misrepresented the organization's independence. While X has since revised its labeling system, many outlets continue to grapple with erroneous representations and Musk's derogatory remarks concerning journalism.
The Guardian's exit adds a new layer to the ongoing debate about the role of newspapers in social media. While abandoning accounts may prevent association with disinformation and harmful rhetoric, it raises concerns about limiting the presence of credible sources to counteract the spread of false narratives. This dilemma has left many media outlets to navigate between maintaining a presence on X to uphold journalistic integrity and the vital need to distance themselves from the platform's increasingly corrosive environment. As the landscape of social media evolves rapidly, the decisions by The Guardian and other remarkable entities may shape new standards and discussions on accountability in digital communication.
Related Sources: