Understanding the Traditions and Mystique of Papal Conclave Smoke Signals
Across the world, attention has recently turned to the chimney atop the Sistine Chapel, a focal point during the papal conclave, where cardinals gather to elect a new pope. The custom of signaling the outcome of their deliberations through smoke has deep historical roots, bringing a mix of anticipation and occasional confusion.
The first confirmed use of smoke to indicate the selection of a pope dates back to 1878, during the conclave that elected Pope Leo XII. However, discussions about the use of smoke extend as far back as 1823, although at that time, it was unclear if the smoke would serve to signal an election result. Prior to 1903, when Pope Pius X was elected, smoke was used solely to signify a failure to elect a new leader, without any distinct colors.
It was not until August 1914, with the election of Pope Benedict XV, that the familiar black and white smoke signals were officially introduced. This system involves burning the ballots along with notes from the participating cardinals, who number 133 in this conclave. According to current rules, the first day allows for just one ballot, while subsequent days involve up to four ballots—two in the morning and two in the afternoon. If a new pope is not chosen, the ballots are burned, resulting in two black smoke signals around noon and later in the evening. On the initial day of the latest conclave, however, the first black smoke unexpectedly emerged at 9 PM, highlighting the process's unpredictability.
If the vote succeeds, white smoke is raised immediately after a ballot, typically around 10:30 AM or 5:30 PM, accompanied by the joyous ringing of bells. The traditional stove has been in use since 1939, initially employed for the election of Pope Pius XII. This cast iron cylinder is approximately one meter tall and features the dates of previous conclaves etched into its dome. It is complemented by a more modern stove that enhances the smoke signals’ clarity by using specific chemicals to generate either black or white smoke.
Historically, using natural materials—like wet straw—led to ambiguity, as the smoke could turn gray or be difficult to interpret, raising questions about the election outcome. A notable incident occurred on October 26, 1958, when white smoke briefly appeared, only to later darken, causing frenzied speculation about a pope being elected. This led to theories circulating about Conservative Cardinal Giuseppe Siri's purported election as Gregory XVII—a claim he consistently denied. Ultimately, two days later, Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli was elected as John XXIII.
Another significant moment arose with Cardinal Albino Luciani, elected on the fourth ballot on August 26, 1978. His election as John Paul I marked historical significance, yet he remains infamous for being the last Italian pope with a remarkably brief tenure of only 33 days. The initial smoke that day was a light gray, prompting uncertainty until the proper announcements were made.
Responding to past confusions surrounding smoke clarity, Pope John Paul II's successor, Pope Benedict XVI, introduced a more advanced system featuring a second stove. In this modern setup, ballots continue to be burned in the old stove, while colored cartridges are added to indicate a clear signal of successful voting outcomes. This innovation made its debut during the 2005 conclave that resulted in Benedict's election. Utilizing chemical additives to produce the smoke—potassium perchlorate for black smoke and potassium chlorate for white—has dramatically improved the visual clarity of the signals. Yellow smoke, which historically served as a functionality test, has since been eliminated to maintain the tradition’s significance.
The ritual of signaling through smoke during the papal conclave not only draws the attention of faith and curiosity worldwide but also embodies centuries of tradition, innovation, and the ongoing evolution of this time-honored practice.
Related Sources: